As far as villas go, I used to love Residencial Hispaniola until apparent rule changes that now require chicas to be in enclosed vehicles; no more walking to-and-fro, so, I haven't stayed there since 2009.
That walk from the discos was a priceless feeling-out process that helped expose the lazy/phony chics or otherwise build up the rapport and (positive) tension. But for me, it's mostly about the price or burden of constantly calling a cab or renting a car nowadays that's mainly ruined it. For those on not so much of a budget, however, or who rent or have access to a car/truck anyway, I highly recommend.
As far as 4 BR villas go in specific, I've stayed in Hispaniola Villa # 17, and that was cool.. on a hill, pool was comparatively well-concealed.. had a gazebo/bar.. only thing I didn't REALLY like was that there were 3 BR's in main house, then a 1 BR guest house type of deal with a private entrance, round the rear garden. In that guest house, some nights, after I thought we'd all retired with our chicas for the night, I'd wake the following morning to a series of hilarious stories re: hoe-swapping, hoe-borrowing, and similar situations that never made it outside to me and my exterior door!
Bookmarks