Not to confuse you even more...
but I would look into the Sosua Bay Beach Club.
http://www.sosuabayresort.com/sosua-bay-beach-club.html
It's the chica friendly side of the Sosua Bay Resort.
$50 per night with free buffet breakfast. Right on the water..20 yards from After one...and 2.5 city blocks from Classicos.
Bookmarks