NewsWhore
05-12-2006, 09:10 PM
Heroin-addicted women should be pressured to take contraception with their treatment, according to a senior back-bench Labour MSP who argued yesterday they were not fit to be parents.
Duncan McNeil, the member for Greenock and Inverclyde and convener of his party's parliamentary group, provoked strong criticism when he suggested the radical measure of putting contraception in methadone to tackle the problem of around 50,000 Scottish children who live with drug-abusing adults.
John Scott, a leading human rights lawyer, said the idea had "hints of the agenda in Nazi Germany, with people getting sterilised".
Neil McKeganey, a drugs expert at Glasgow University, said it was necessary to limit the rights of drug abusers to have children because of the harm their children face. Last year, he courted controversy by suggesting that drug-abusing women could be paid to be on contraception.
Mr McNeil floated his methadone idea during a Holyrood debate about children at risk from drug abusers. He asked MSPs: "Why are we in a situation where so many of those who are addicted to drugs are having children?"
He spoke of the dangers of HIV and Aids and went on: "There are dangers to the mother and child from a difficult pregnancy. As a first step, we need to explore putting some form of oral contraception in methadone, or using other methods. That way, we could reduce this problem and prevent some of those children coming to harm."
Afterwards, he backed away from making this compulsory, saying the mixed contraceptive and methadone could be "strongly advised".
"Can we say as a society that it's right for us to try to intervene and say it's not a good idea when you're living a chaotic lifestyle and on drugs to get pregnant because it could kill you, you could pass on HIV/Aids to your child, you are not fit to have a baby?"
Susan Deacon, the former Labour health minister, had suggested earlier in the debate that addicted women should be offered the "informed choice" of long-term contraceptive injections, costing £90 each.
An executive spokesman said Mr McNeil's idea was "not something we're likely to consider", while the opposition was scathing about it.
Fiona Hyslop, SNP children's spokesman, said the idea was extreme, wrong and unworkable. "We need a serious, mature and rational debate about this issue, and these remarks are none of these things."
Jeremy Purvis, for the Liberal Democrats, said the idea was bizarre, impractical and probably illegal, while Tommy Sheridan, of the Scottish Socialists, said it was "stupid, pathetic and ignorant of the real problems that exist in drug abuse".
Annabel Goldie, Scottish Tory leader, said: "Anyone coming forward for assistance with their drug addiction needs positive help, not barriers put in their way. Contraceptive advice should be offered, available and indeed encouraged, but it cannot be made compulsory."
Dr McKeganey, director of the centre for drug misuse research at Glasgow, said the case for contraception to reduce unwanted pregnancies was "the great unspoken" in the drugs debate. However, it was "a nettle that has to be grasped."
Heroin-addicted women should be pressured to take contraception with their treatment, according to a senior back-bench Labour MSP who argued yesterday they were not fit to be parents.
Duncan McNeil, the member for Greenock and Inverclyde and convener of his party's parliamentary group, provoked strong criticism when he suggested the radical measure of putting contraception in methadone to tackle the problem of around 50,000 Scottish children who live with drug-abusing adults.
John Scott, a leading human rights lawyer, said the idea had "hints of the agenda in Nazi Germany, with people getting sterilised".
Neil McKeganey, a drugs expert at Glasgow University, said it was necessary to limit the rights of drug abusers to have children because of the harm their children face. Last year, he courted controversy by suggesting that drug-abusing women could be paid to be on contraception.
[/URL] (http://feeds.feedburner.com/~f/Sxxxyorg?a=wIWKzJmg) [URL=http://feeds.feedburner.com/~f/Sxxxyorg?a=JlqzOiki] (http://feeds.feedburner.com/~f/Sxxxyorg?a=tMvcGeeV)
Link To Original Article (http://feeds.feedburner.com/Sxxxyorg?m=1648)
Duncan McNeil, the member for Greenock and Inverclyde and convener of his party's parliamentary group, provoked strong criticism when he suggested the radical measure of putting contraception in methadone to tackle the problem of around 50,000 Scottish children who live with drug-abusing adults.
John Scott, a leading human rights lawyer, said the idea had "hints of the agenda in Nazi Germany, with people getting sterilised".
Neil McKeganey, a drugs expert at Glasgow University, said it was necessary to limit the rights of drug abusers to have children because of the harm their children face. Last year, he courted controversy by suggesting that drug-abusing women could be paid to be on contraception.
Mr McNeil floated his methadone idea during a Holyrood debate about children at risk from drug abusers. He asked MSPs: "Why are we in a situation where so many of those who are addicted to drugs are having children?"
He spoke of the dangers of HIV and Aids and went on: "There are dangers to the mother and child from a difficult pregnancy. As a first step, we need to explore putting some form of oral contraception in methadone, or using other methods. That way, we could reduce this problem and prevent some of those children coming to harm."
Afterwards, he backed away from making this compulsory, saying the mixed contraceptive and methadone could be "strongly advised".
"Can we say as a society that it's right for us to try to intervene and say it's not a good idea when you're living a chaotic lifestyle and on drugs to get pregnant because it could kill you, you could pass on HIV/Aids to your child, you are not fit to have a baby?"
Susan Deacon, the former Labour health minister, had suggested earlier in the debate that addicted women should be offered the "informed choice" of long-term contraceptive injections, costing £90 each.
An executive spokesman said Mr McNeil's idea was "not something we're likely to consider", while the opposition was scathing about it.
Fiona Hyslop, SNP children's spokesman, said the idea was extreme, wrong and unworkable. "We need a serious, mature and rational debate about this issue, and these remarks are none of these things."
Jeremy Purvis, for the Liberal Democrats, said the idea was bizarre, impractical and probably illegal, while Tommy Sheridan, of the Scottish Socialists, said it was "stupid, pathetic and ignorant of the real problems that exist in drug abuse".
Annabel Goldie, Scottish Tory leader, said: "Anyone coming forward for assistance with their drug addiction needs positive help, not barriers put in their way. Contraceptive advice should be offered, available and indeed encouraged, but it cannot be made compulsory."
Dr McKeganey, director of the centre for drug misuse research at Glasgow, said the case for contraception to reduce unwanted pregnancies was "the great unspoken" in the drugs debate. However, it was "a nettle that has to be grasped."
Heroin-addicted women should be pressured to take contraception with their treatment, according to a senior back-bench Labour MSP who argued yesterday they were not fit to be parents.
Duncan McNeil, the member for Greenock and Inverclyde and convener of his party's parliamentary group, provoked strong criticism when he suggested the radical measure of putting contraception in methadone to tackle the problem of around 50,000 Scottish children who live with drug-abusing adults.
John Scott, a leading human rights lawyer, said the idea had "hints of the agenda in Nazi Germany, with people getting sterilised".
Neil McKeganey, a drugs expert at Glasgow University, said it was necessary to limit the rights of drug abusers to have children because of the harm their children face. Last year, he courted controversy by suggesting that drug-abusing women could be paid to be on contraception.
[/URL] (http://feeds.feedburner.com/~f/Sxxxyorg?a=wIWKzJmg) [URL=http://feeds.feedburner.com/~f/Sxxxyorg?a=JlqzOiki] (http://feeds.feedburner.com/~f/Sxxxyorg?a=tMvcGeeV)
Link To Original Article (http://feeds.feedburner.com/Sxxxyorg?m=1648)